9 criteria comparedWe build with bothNo sign-up needed
Shopify
A hosted platform that handles checkout, security and scale for you.
Launch in weeksHosted & secureHuge app store
VS
Custom store
A storefront and backend built for your exact catalogue and rules.
Any business ruleNo platform feesYou own it
The short answer
Which one should you choose?
Most merchants should start on Shopify. A custom store earns its cost when your pricing, ordering or fulfilment rules do not fit a standard cart.
Option A
Choose Shopify if
You want to be selling within weeks
Your catalogue and checkout are fairly standard
You do not want to manage servers, security or PCI compliance
You want apps for reviews, subscriptions and email ready to install
Your team is non-technical and will run the store daily
Option B
Choose Custom store if
Pricing depends on customer, quantity, location or quotes
You sell B2B with credit limits, approvals or custom catalogues
The buying flow is a configurator, booking or made-to-order process
Platform and app fees have become a large monthly cost
The store must be deeply tied into your ERP or production system
Side by side
Shopify and Custom store, criterion by criterion.
“Edge” marks the option that usually comes out ahead. Where neither is marked, it depends on your situation.
0Shopify edges
Custom store edges0
Criterion
Shopify
Custom store
Time to launch
Weeks
A few months
Upfront cost
Low: theme, set-up and a few apps
Higher: design and development from scratch
Running cost
Monthly plan, app subscriptions and transaction fees
Hosting and maintenance, no platform cut
Checkout control
Limited to what the plan and extensions allow
Every step is yours to design
Complex pricing & B2B rules
Possible with apps or Plus; can get awkward
Built exactly as your business needs
Security & uptime
Handled by Shopify
Your responsibility, with your development partner
Apps & integrations
Thousands of ready-made apps
Anything, but each one is built or integrated
Ownership & portability
Platform lock-in; themes and apps do not transfer
Code and data are fully yours
Performance tuning
Good by default; limited deep control
Fully tunable for your traffic and catalogue
This comparison reflects our experience at the time of writing. Features, pricing and licensing of third-party products change, so check current details with the provider.
One-minute quiz
Answer 4 questions, see where you lean.
Nothing is stored or sent. The result updates as you answer.
How standard is the way customers buy from you?
When do you need to launch?
Who will manage the store day to day?
How important is avoiding platform and app fees?
Before you decide
Three things worth knowing.
There is a middle path
A custom Shopify app or a headless front-end gives you tailored features while Shopify still runs checkout and payments.
Add up all the monthly fees
Plan, apps and transaction fees together tell you when a custom build would pay for itself.
Protect your SEO when moving
Whichever way you migrate, map old URLs to new ones so rankings carry over.
FAQ
Questions, answered.
Can’t find yours? Ask us, we reply within a business day.